Is It a Church?

By Chaplain Mike

Damaris sent me a link to an article that appeared in our local Indianapolis paper the other day. You can read it HERE.

The title on the web-edition was, “Brownsburg Church Promotes God as an Expert on Sex.” I think the print edition ran a title something like, “Sex, Drugs, and Rock-n-Roll,” and both used a subtitle that talked about how “alternative” churches are reaching out to the unchurched in their communities with “innovative” approaches.

Let’s skip the obvious temptation to talk about sex here, and get to the deeper issues this article raises.

The piece quotes Philip Goff, director of the Center for the Study of Religion and American Culture at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, who says,

A growing number of mostly startup churches are trying increasingly creative approaches to appeal to people who have either strayed from church or had no interest in organized religion, Goff said.

“One of the things many of these new churches are trying to do is imitate culture to bring in people, instead of sitting back and critiquing it,” he said. “This is a trend that is going to be with us for a long time, because preachers are realizing they may have to turn to nontraditional means to attract younger members.”

The article mentions other “non-traditional” ways churches are reaching out, “such as tattoo parlors, music venues or even bars. They may host heavy-metal concerts, skateboard competitions, motorcycle shows or even body-piercing events to spread their message.” One church promotes its ministry with business cards that use the slogan, “Hate Religion?” written in the style of a blood smear. “Other churches have begun to draw younger crowds with rock music and a come-as-you-are message,” such as the Current Church in my own town of Franklin, which shares building space with a Christian concert venue called “The Gear.” The article says this style has allowed them to attract “a mostly 25-and-younger crowd” that would normally not be interested in church.

Two things I would like to say in response to this author’s observations.

  • One, this is not news. We in the Christian culture have been watching this happen for years. Internet Monk itself has been looking at these developments and critiquing them for over a decade now.
  • Two, what I wonder is: can we call these communities “Churches” in the truest Biblical, historic, and traditional sense of the term?

Without denigrating what these folks are trying to do, I sincerely wonder: IS THIS CHURCH?

I am going to argue, “No.”

Continue reading “Is It a Church?”

Open Mic: Teaching about Creation

By Chaplain Mike

Internet Monk reader Ben sent in the following question, asking for counsel from our IM community.

Dear Chaplain Mike,

On Friday, I’ve got 30 minutes to talk to a group of 11-13 year-olds about ‘creation and evolution’.

They haven’t studied anything about either at school, and in the context of the church they go to, there isn’t a great deal of pressure for me to push things either way.

I’m a bit stumped about where to even start: creation/evolution, religion/science, Genesis/Gilgamesh?!

I may just be able to ask them questions and improvise from there, but I’d quite like a backup plan…

I’d be interested to know what advice Internet Monk readers might have.

Regards,
Ben S

Let’s help a brother out, folks.

How would you approach teaching these young people?

A Letter from Gilead

By Chaplain Mike

My dearest children,

This weekend I had the profound pleasure to visit with the Rev. John Ames, a Congregational minister from Gilead, Iowa. He came to my attention and told me his stories through Marilynne Robinson’s Pulitzer Prize winning novel, Gilead.

Hearing him speak and weave his tales was a revelation, I must say.

Like you, John was born into a preacher’s family. However, unlike our family, the vocation of minister was everywhere among his kin, on both his father and mother’s side. It was in their blood.

Ames’s father and grandfather were particularly strong influences on him. His father’s father was a legendary, larger than life figure who had moved from Maine to Kansas in the 1830’s to support the abolitionists. Over the years, he kept a lot of secrets about his activities in Kansas–it was a wild and tempestuous era in our history–and it’s likely he had a great deal of human frailty and perhaps downright impiety to confess to the Lord when all was said and done. He joined a graybeard regiment in the Civil War and ended up losing an eye, came home and moved in with his son’s family for a time, and then ran back off to Kansas, where he died in a town that died too, because of the railroad and drought.

One of the formative events in John’s life was when his father took the boy (at age twelve) and set off to find the old man’s grave. They had a hard time of it, travel being what it was then, and the parchedness making food and comfort hard to come by. They put themselves at great risk of dying themselves, out there in that desolate land. But John’s father had to make the journey. The last words he and his own father had exchanged were angry and bitter, and it drove him to find one last way to honor the man.

Father and son finally found the unkempt graveyard, which John describes as “just a patch of ground with a half-fallen fence around it and gate on a chain weighted with a cowbell.” They fixed up the fence as best they could. Then, borrowing some tools from a nearby farmhouse, they tended to the ground, cutting the brush, righting the falling markers, and being careful not to tread on the graves. After scattering flower seeds they had carried from their own garden, John’s father offered a prayer, asking for pardon and remembering his father to the Lord.

It was during that prayer that John had an epiphany. I will let him describe it.

Moonrise, Berberian

Every prayer seemed long to me at that age, and I was truly bone tired. I tried to keep my eyes closed, but after a while I had to look around a little. And this is something I remember very well. At first I thought I saw the sun setting in the east; I knew where east was, because the sun was just over the horizon when we got there that morning. Then I realized that what I saw was a full moon rising just as the sun was going down. Each of them was standing on its edge, with the most wonderful light between them. It seemed as if you could touch it, as if there were palpable currents of light passing back and forth, or as if there were great taut skeins of light suspended between them. I wanted my father to see it, but I knew I’d have to startle him out of his prayer, and I wanted to do it the best way, so I took his hand and kissed it. And then I said, “Look at the moon.” And he did. We just stood there until the sun was down and the moon was up. They seemed to float on the horizon for quite a long time. I suppose because they were both so bright you couldn’t get a clear look at them. And that grave, and my father and I, were exactly between them, which seemed amazing to me at the time, since I hadn’t given much thought to the nature of the horizon.

My father said, “I would never have thought this place could be beautiful. I’m glad to know that.”

And that, dear children, is one of the main things you should know about John Ames. He’s learned what it means to stand squarely between the horizons, and he can describe the light.

Continue reading “A Letter from Gilead”

Jesus Teaches God’s Laws

Return of the Prodigal Son, Rembrandt

By Chaplain Mike
Today’s Gospel: Matthew 5:21-37

what kind of world would it be…

if we heard his laws with diff’rent ears
if we heard them not as classroom rules
designed to keep us all in line —
sit up straight
eyes to the front
hands to yourself
lips sealed —
you’d better straighten up, mister
or there’ll be hell to pay!

what kind of world would it be…

if instead we felt our father’s heart break
each time we fumed and fussed and spewed
hateful words and evil looks
little knowing in our rage
the sick’ning ache within his gut
the wave of grief, the deep despair
how much he hates our hate
it might as well be
murder

iMonk Classic: “I Forgive Myself” — The Hardest Word?

Classic iMonk Post
by Michael Spencer
From Feb 19, 2008

One of the things I really don’t like about run-of-the-mill evangelical spirituality is the assumption that we’re all basically clones of each other. Cheerful clones. Mentally healthy clones. Good family clones. Conservative political clones. Happy at church clones. Like the same music clones. Clones who cope well. Clones who think alike. Clones who can take a cheerful verse and dissolve any problem in short order.

Let me take a simple thing. I don’t like Fox News. I don’t have a vendetta about it, but it’s inflammatory much of the time, and their overall harping tone doesn’t do a thing for my blood pressure. They do a lot of name calling, cheap shots, girly pics and “true crime” coverage. I don’t live in England, so I don’t want the screaming British media.

What would be my fate if I stood up at my next public gathering with conservative evangelicals and read the previous paragraph? Let’s just say that many judgments would be made on this one item, most of them far from true.

We aren’t alike, but there’s a kind of desperate, weird, compulsion to act like we are alike; a compulsion that causes many Christians to walk around carrying the burden of an entirely false self. Their struggles, scars, questions, confusions, missteps, short-comings, darkness and brokenness are going to be a secret.

If…if…we broke those secrets, what would we learn?

Continue reading “iMonk Classic: “I Forgive Myself” — The Hardest Word?”

Saturday Ramblings 2.12.11

So, have you finished all of your leftover Superb Owl snacks yet? Have you taken down your Superb Owl decorations? Had enough football? Had enough of us referring to the Big Game as the Superb Owl? Well, sports fans, here is some good news: Pitchers and catchers report in four days to Spring Training. You have just enough time for today’s helping of Saturday Ramblings before you break out your baseball gear.

Yesterday’s resignation of Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak may have little effect on that country’s Christian minority. Christians have been under increased persecution by their Muslim neighbors in the past months. And yet … yet there is some hope, as Ashley Makar of Killing The Buddha relates. It seems that Christians formed a protective ring around a group of Muslims as the Muslims prayed. And then the Muslims returned the favor as the Christians celebrated Mass. Yes, there is hope indeed wherever love is practiced.

Who didn’t see this coming? You can now make your confession without leaving the comfort of your iPhone. The Catholic Church approved an app called simply Confession for use on your iPhone, iPod touch and iPad. Accessible thru the iTunes store, Confession can create for you a custom examination of your conscience and direct you through the sacrament. (I cannot wait for Martha to weigh in on this.) Now if there was just an app that committed the sin for you, you would not be necessary at all.

Continue reading “Saturday Ramblings 2.12.11”

Catechism: A Final Word (for now)

Luther's Small Catechism, 1529

By Chaplain Mike

A number of years ago, after having read some books by J.I. Packer, including the classic Knowing God, I picked up a small book he had written called, Growing in Christ. It claimed to be a guide to Christian basics, and it focused on the Apostles’ Creed, the Sacraments, the Lord’s Prayer, and the Ten Commandments.

How odd! I thought. Why would someone choose those particular texts as a foundation for making disciples?

I was confused. Didn’t Packer know about the Navigators memory program or Campus Crusade’s follow-up studies for the Four Spiritual Laws? Why, one of those texts he was calling us to study isn’t even Scripture! And what’s all this “sacrament” stuff? Didn’t he know that infant baptism has no Biblical basis? And sure, Communion is special, but why talk about it in a book about basic Christian beliefs?

Such was the extent of my youthful evangelical ignorance.

Valedictorian at Bible college and I didn’t really know much about the Reformation or, indeed, anything at all about the history and traditions of the church. I was a “solo Scriptura” kind of guy. And all the poorer for it.

It’s time to give Dr. Packer his due for bringing the concept of the Reformation catechism back and introducing it to clueless evangelicals like me. As one small act of penance, I will let him have the last word this week on the subject.

Continue reading “Catechism: A Final Word (for now)”

Our Digital Life: Perils & Possibilities

By Chaplain Mike

In our discussions about catechetical teaching this week, issues were raised with respect to this age of digital communication in which we now live.

Greg, for example, commented, “…we are facing not just illiteracy, but an epistemology shift. Not only is generation next learning in different ways, it seems they flat do not trust the old ones. Somebody needs to take a stand for the written word in a way that does not trash nano technology whole cloth. This will take some thought and wisdom.”

Then the other night I saw that Frontline (PBS) was airing a program called, Digital Nation: Life on the Virtual Frontier. Did you get a chance to watch it?

The introduction to the website that accompanies this program says:

Within a single generation, digital media and the World Wide Web have transformed virtually every aspect of modern culture, from the way we learn and work to the ways in which we socialize and even conduct war. But is the technology moving faster than we can adapt to it? And is our 24/7 wired world causing us to lose as much as we’ve gained?

In the program, producer Rachel Dretzin and commentator Douglas Rushkoff lead a tour of this new world. Rushkoff was once an enthusiastic proponent for internet technology, claiming that it was leading to a significant step in the evolution of humanity. Now, however, he wonders “whether or not we are tinkering with something more essential than we realize.”

The first part of the program focused on some of the most gifted students in the United States and their reflections on how being constantly connected via digital communication has affected their learning and their lives.

Continue reading “Our Digital Life: Perils & Possibilities”