“The Church’s Richest Jewels”

Lord’s Prayer, Cranach (detail)

In 1539, late in his career, Martin Luther wrote “On the Councils and the Church.” One avenue for reformation that Luther and others had regularly called for was a church council. Over the course of time, however, Luther became disillusioned that a “free, Christian council” could be convened that would properly reform the church and the papacy. In fact, as time went on, it became apparent that any church council would probably condemn the reformers rather than the Roman church.

On a previous occasion, we ran a post sketching Martin Luther’s “marks of the church” laid out in this treatise. Today I will quote a precious passage from this work, which sets forth Luther’s conclusion that the primary way God preserves his church is not through big actions like convening councils, but through the daily faithful work of pastors and those who educate our children.

Here is yet another reminder that our God is not in the wind, fire, or earthquake, but in the quiet speaking of his word, the simple faith of his people, and good works of love toward our neighbors.

But in this empire of the church, the rule is, “The word of our God will stand for ever” (Isa. 40:8). One has to live according to it and refrain from creating new or different words of God and from establishing new and different articles of faith. That is why pastors and schoolteachers are the lowly, but daily, permanent, eternal judges who anathematize without interruption, that is, fend off the devil and his raging. A council, being a great judge, must make old, great rascals pious or kill them, but it cannot produce any others. A pastor and schoolteacher deal with small, young rascals and constantly train new people to become bishops and councils, whenever it is necessary. A council prunes the large limbs from the tree or extirpates evil trees. But a pastor and a schoolteacher plant and cultivate young trees and useful shrubs in the garden. Oh, they have a precious office and task, and they are the church’s richest jewels; they preserve the church. Therefore all the lords should do their part to preserve pastors and schools. For if indeed we cannot have councils, the parishes and schools, small though they are, are eternal and useful councils. (emphasis mine)

Denise Spencer: Leading Music in a Small Catholic Parish

St. Ann Mission, Manchester KY

NOTE from CM: One thing I wanted to accomplish during Church Music Month was to let us hear from people who are working week-in and week-out to serve local congregations in music ministry. It’s all well and good to talk about our “theology of worship” or to discuss such matters theoretically. But when it comes right down to it, there is a multitude of faithful people in churches and parishes all around the world who love to sing, play, make music, and join together with others to help them do the same, for the glory of God and the blessing of his people.

Our friend Denise Spencer is one of those people. Denise and Michael served together in ministry for many years, just as Gail and I have, and music has been an integral part of how they have worshiped God and ministered to others in churches and at the school where Denise continues to work. Denise now serves her small Catholic parish in this way, and I thought it would be enlightening to see how music is being used to serve the church in a beautiful little Catholic congregation in the hills of Kentucky.

* * *

Leading Music in a Small Catholic Parish
by Denise Day Spencer

Chaplain Mike asked me to write an essay about leading music in a small Catholic parish. What are some of the challenges? The rewards?

I am sure a small Catholic parish faces many of the same challenges as any small Protestant church. Where are the people who are able and willing to work with the music ministry? The key word is often “willing.” Some would be able, but are already overextended in other ministries or are too busy with their lives outside of church. Still others have the ability to help, but are too shy and hold back in self-doubt.

There are days when I imagine our parishioners wish I would hold back myself. But willingness wins the day and I bang out the next hymn on the piano. I take solace in the belief that St. Ann Mission truly needs me, for they asked me to play at Mass well before I joined the Church.

Continue reading “Denise Spencer: Leading Music in a Small Catholic Parish”

The Campaign Ad We’ll Never See (Too Bad)

Voiceover: And now for a joint message from President Barack Obama and Governor Mitt Romney…

OBAMA: As the election draws near, we thought it would be a good idea to do the right thing in this campaign, and tell the truth to the people of the United States of America. The fact is, despite what both of us have been saying out there on the stump, and despite what all those groups that have spent millions and millions of dollars attacking both of us have been saying in their propaganda ads, Governor Romney and I really aren’t that much different, and don’t offer a drastically different vision for our country.

ROMNEY: Well said, Mr. President. You are absolutely right. In the final analysis we may disagree about how to accomplish certain things, but we are actually both pretty similar. We both believe in the power of the office of the presidency and the institutions of federal government; otherwise why would we have devoted so much time out of our lives and so much energy to pursue the position? At heart we are both statists — we believe in the power of the federal government to control economic and social policy as well as provide basic defense and promote the general welfare through federal governance.

OBAMA: You’re right, Governor Romney. I don’t think there is any genuine difference between us at that fundamental level. Now you come at that from a slightly right-of-center position, and I come at it from slightly left-of-center stance, but we’re both sold on federal power and influence as a major driver for our way forward as a nation.

ROMNEY: Mr. President, I also think we both know that there is only so much we can do in the position of president. The economy, for example. Presidents always get way too much credit or criticism for that. President Bush was unfortunate enough to have to deal with the aftermath of September 11 in his presidency, and later a near-total meltdown of the financial system. He’s lucky to have escaped being branded as another Herbert Hoover! And then all of that was handed to you. All in all, we’ve been pretty fortunate.

OBAMA: In contrast, presidents like Reagan and Clinton, who get great credit for their economic policies, were in office during boom-times. Of course they were successful! Also, many people forget that presidents have Congress to deal with — which, I can tell you, is a total crap-shoot. [laughter] Imagine if your “success” was dependent on several hundred other people who can’t get along with each other!

Bottom-line, Mr. Governor, we both know that timing is everything. So, we do the best we can. And I think both you and I would admit that neither one of us is the kind of visionary leader that is going to totally transform the future!

ROMNEY: Isn’t that the truth! [laughter] In that light, I’d like to point out that there is something else about which we agree — we both know that leading this country most of the time is a matter of taking moderate positions on issues, negotiating and working with people with whom we disagree, and practicing compromise and common sense — pretty mundane stuff. This campaign (and the general atmosphere in our country) has been just the opposite of all that. We’ve both had to deal with the extremists on the far end of our parties who can only see things in black and white and can only think in terms of winning and losing.

OBAMA: We are never going to please them, and truth be told, we aren’t ever really going to try! But we’ll keep taking their money and letting them run their attack ads, won’t we? [laughter]

ROMNEY: I want the people of the United States to know that Barack Obama has been a pretty darned good president. He has had his failures just like all of us who take on great tasks, and like I said, I would approach some things differently, but we owe him a debt of gratitude for serving our country in this most difficult of positions and in a challenging season in our national life. If he is reelected, I will be the first to shake his hand and offer my loyal support. I have no doubt he would do a great job if elected to a second term.

OBAMA: Why, thank you for those generous words, Governor Romney. In response, I will tell the people of our country that I appreciate Mitt Romney and think he would be an excellent choice as our next president. Despite the nearly apocalyptic rhetoric of this campaign, his vision of America is not all that different from mine. We both want people to be free and prosperous and secure. We want families to flourish and communities to thrive. We want to protect our nation and do what we can to secure our future.

ROMNEY: That’s right. And whether it gets done from the right-of-center position that I take, or the left-of-center position of President Obama, what matters is that we work together as fellow Americans to see that it happens.

OBAMA: Of course, both Governor Romney and I want to be the next president and we believe in our abilities to do the job and do it well, with God’s help. We may share a lot in common, but we’re not identical, and we encourage each voter to be well-informed when you go to the polls and vote on Nov. 6. Ultimately, the choice is yours.

OBAMA AND ROMNEY: So, may God bless my opponent. And may God bless each voter. And may God bless America.

____________

This ad has been paid for by U.S. Citizens for Truth and Common Sense in Campaigning.

“A Good Christian Is Always an Infant”

Sacramental Thoughts for Sundays
Sunday, October 28, 2012

“A Good Christian is Always an Infant,” from Luther: Man Between God and the Devil, by Heiko Oberman

* * *

…for Luther this constituted a decisive point. Infant baptism revealed the meaning of  baptism. From Luther’s standpoint one could not genuinely preserve baptism while repudiating infant baptism, for it was in the child to be baptized that the meaning of Evangelical faith became visible: trusting only in the “alien” justification granted by God; acting out of the “alien,” the new conscience; and living on the intercession of others. Where one’s own faith begins to waver, the alien faith appears on the scene. And this is the exact situation of the “infant,” for whom the Church, godparents, and parents believe vicariously. The baptismal font is the reservoir of alien righteousness surrounded by alien belief.

For enlightened Protestantism, which has developed faith into a rational system and eliminated the Devil from it, this belief is not alien, but alienating and peculiar. Luther, however, insists on this very alienation when faced with the menace of an intellectualization of faith: if the Devil is to be withstood, intercession is indispensable; “loners” are defenseless against his threat and subject to his tyranny. A good Christian is always an infant in his dependence on God and in the way he is bound up with Christ and His Church.

Saturday Ramblings 10.27.12

Welcome to the annual edition of Saturday Ramblings where we eagerly await those little people all dressed up in strange costumes who come to our door wanting something from us. No, not the trick or treaters. I’m talking about political pollsters. Imagine their surprise when I tell them I’m voting straight party line this year, as long as I can find a box on the ballet for the Flat Earth Society. Seriously, I thought one of the rights we have in this nation is the secret ballot. So why do we have so many “reporters” who want to know who I’m voting for, or who I did vote for? Sigh … I guess I’ll just have to get used to it. So I’m here now to tell you who I’m using my vote on in the presidential race. I’m voting for … what? really? Oh, sorry, my choice will have to wait. It’s time to ramble!

Billy Graham has given his endorsement to Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, and it has caused him no end of trouble. The question many are asking is, Is Billy Graham really behind this, or is it more a move by his son, Franklin? Christianity Today asked three who know Graham well what they think. His grandson, Tullian Tchividjian, says there is no way anyone in the BGEA woud have come up with the ads, etc., if Graham had not agreed to it. Roland Martin says Graham’s Bible must be different from his.

Many argue against the idea that President Obama is a Christian at all. And if he is, then he is the wrong kind of Christian.

Continue reading “Saturday Ramblings 10.27.12”

iMonk Book Club

Chaplain Mike is having trouble with his internet connection today. Apparently the hamster that spins the wheel generating ‘lectricity in  his part of the world died, and no replacement hamster was available. Thus, it is up to me to come up with something sage and wonderful.

Unfortunately, the hamster that turns my “sage and wonderful” wheel died a loooooong time ago. So let’s spend this brief time together talking about our upcoming iMonk Book Club. We are going to read four books together in November, one each week, and then gather our chairs in a circle and talk about the ideas in these books.

Week one: Glorious Ruin: How Suffering Sets You Free by Tullian Tchividjian.  I’ll lead this discussion. This book is not so much about suffering as it is about experiencing God’s grace in a very radical way.

Week two: Miracles: A Journalist Looks at Modern Day Experiences of God’s Power by Tim Stafford. Does God perform miracles still today? A lot of people say that he does, and they have proof. But does their “proof” stand up to medical, scientific, and journalistic scrutiny? Lisa Dye will lead this discussion.

Week three: Is God a Moral Monster?: Making Sense of the Old Testament God by Paul Copan. Just what do we make of a God who orders entire people groups to be exterminated? Who seems to encourage slavery? Who delights in blood sacrifices? Craig Bubeck is not afraid to look at these hard questions, even when there does not seem to be a good answer.

Week four: Julian of Norwich: A Contemplative Biography by Amy Frykholm.  Just who was Julian? Why do her writings still stand true more than 600 years later? What can we learn from a woman who lived most of her life in a small, stone cell attached to a small church in a small English village? Damaris Zehner and Martha of Ireland look at Julian and her times.

Your assignment is to choose one, two, three or all four books, read them, and come up with some good questions and ideas to share with us. If there is one thing I know you iMonks like more than your beer, it’s reading and talking about what you’ve read. Now, get to it.

And if you happen to have a spare hamster you can lend to Chaplain Mike …

Right Where I Belong

Green Acres Market

I read Chaplain Mike’s post yesterday afternoon (Get Small) with delight. I had just read that very passage from Tullian Tchividjian’s Glorious Ruin that morning. And it is something the Holy Spirit has been speaking to me for several days. To paraphrase the A Team’s Hannibal Smith, don’t you just love it when God’s plan comes together?

For so very long I was caught up in the notion that the way to please God the most was to have a bigger “ministry” than I had currently. That I was to strive to get bigger, to do more, to expand, to always become  new and improved. This is a ministry model based on our current business culture. Your local hardware store refused to grow beyond its one location and is now gone, replaced by big box stores that are always looking to grow. The same applies to ministries. You want to find some way to provide clothing for single moms? Great. How, how can you cast that vision to cities beyond yours? Did you file the paperwork to ensure your 501(c)3 status? Are you gathering testimonies so you can write a book about your successes? (You’ll need that to sell when you go on your speaking tour.)

Or you plant a church. Great. Churches are wonderful things, except when they stay small and only interact with those within walking distance. No, to be a successful church you’ll need to lay plans for multiple sites, connected by video so that you, the speaker, can talk to everyone at all locations. Small churches are loser churches. We all know that.

So here I was, a successful literary agent, representing some of the biggest names in Christian publishing, when the book world went upside-down (just as I had predicted it would, right when I predicted it would). I was big, dammit, too big to fail. But fail I did. I went from a nearly six-figure income to working at Target for just above minimum wage. It was not only humbling, it was humiliating. I got behind on bills. I couldn’t buy Christmas gifts for my kids or grandkids. I went from eating out to doing without eating. I had to learn to receive from others instead of giving. Everything I thought was important went away. I was no longer big or important to anyone in any way. Except I began to be able to help customers who came to buy TVs and cameras from me. They became my friends, and they would ask me to pray for them. As I got to know my coworkers, they, too, began to ask for prayer. Or just come to me because they needed to be encouraged.

Continue reading “Right Where I Belong”

Pictures Of Fall

My favorite time of year is autumn. I love the colors, the smells, the crispness of the air. Recently my camera and I ventured out to enjoy a fall day in Oklahoma (with one picture from Louisville tucked in). Even if fall is not your favorite time of year, I hope you enjoy.

Cuban Taxi
Who, me?
Ghost pumpkins
Colorful gourds
Wagonload of squash

Get Small

Leaves against the Sky, D. Cornwell

The world tells us in a thousand different ways that the bigger we become, the freer we will be. The richer, the more beautiful, and the more powerful we grow, the more security, liberty, and happiness we will experience. And yet, the gospel tells us just the opposite, that the smaller we become, the freer we will be.

The gospel is for the defeated, not the dominant. …In view of God’s holiness, we are all losers (Rom. 3:23). We are all sufferers. We are all sinners. The distinction between winners and losers is irrelevant when no one can claim victory.

Instead, the gospel is for those who have realized that they can’t carry the weight of the world on their shoulders. Only when God drives us to the end of ourselves do we begin to see life in the gospel. Which is another way of saying that only those who stand in need of a savior will look for or recognize a savior. Fortunately, Christianity in its original, most authentic expression understands God chiefly as savior and human beings chiefly as those in need of being saved.

– Tullian Tchividjian
Freedom in Smallness

* * *

Visit David Cornwell’s Photostream. Pictures used by permission.

Interview: Miguel Ruiz (part one)

Note from CM: Miguel Ruiz is one of our most thoughtful commenters here on IM. When Miguel and his wife were on their way east to take a position in a church on Long Island, he stopped here in Indianapolis and we spent some time talking face to face, something I wish I had a chance to do with so many more of you.

In both of our situations, our post-evangelical journey led us to the Lutheran tradition. Miguel is now Music Minister and Teacher at Our Savior Lutheran Church in Centereach, NY, on Long Island. Miguel’s a busy guy, and I’m happy that he agreed to do an interview with us for Church Music Month.

Today we feature part one.

* * *

Miguel, since you are a regular commenter on Internet Monk, how about if you would start by telling us a little bit about your own personal journey as a Christian and musician, and the part Michael Spencer played in that.

I discovered iMonk at a rather pivotal time in my life, during the process of walking away from my first position in church work out of college, feeling quite embittered and disillusioned. The next experienced lasted twice as long and ended just as bad. At some point you begin to ask questions, like what is it that causes over-churched evangelicals to argue ad infinitum about trivial matters, betray each other in petty power plays, and care so little about working together and reconciliation? As I embarked on a period of Cartesian doubt, I knew something was missing from the picture, or a misplaced focus in the life of the church.

Of course, Jesus was the missing focal point. As I wandered my post-evangelical sojourn in search of a religious home, Spencer’s writing was a constant source of encouragement, enlightenment, and direction. The website served as an online hub and portal to my theological self-education as I tried to nail down where in Mere Christianity I belonged. The community here also served as a sounding board for the things I was learning and a safe place to discuss and exchange ideas without threatening my job security.

As Spencer went through his Calvinist phase, I was very attracted to the God-centeredness of many reformation leaning teachers, and soon came to the conclusion that I would settle with one of the original reformation churches. Thus began my confessional identity search. As I dug through the doctrinal writings of the established church traditions, I begin to find Jesus in places I never thought of before. It didn’t help much that the new management at IM had walked the Wittenberg trail already. I eventually became drawn to the Jesus-shaped spirituality of confessional Lutheranism, and you can read about my reasons for conversion here.

Music guys rarely get their choice of denomination. Most music ministers I know have had to bounce around quite a bit. One day your Methodist, the next you’re Presbyterian. But by God’s grace I was able to find a home and a job in the LCMS very quickly, though it did involve moving from SoCal to Long Island.

Continue reading “Interview: Miguel Ruiz (part one)”