By Chaplain Mike
According to Warren Cole Smith in his book, A Lover’s Quarrel with the Evangelical Church (full review to come later this weekend), short-term mission trips may be more of a problem than a productive way of doing the work of Christ’s Kingdom.
He cites Robert Priest, professor of mission and intercultural studies at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, who said:
The number of lay people in the United States involved in short-term missions grew from an estimated 540 in 1965 to 22,000 in 1979. By 1989 it had grown to an estimated 120,000. three years later the figure had doubled to 250,000. It is now estimated that there were at least on million short-termers in 2003.
Source: “Short-term Mission Trip, or Donor-Paid Vacation?”
by Brittany Smith (Evangelical Press News Service, 10/19/06)
Estimates today range from 1-4 million North Americans taking short-term trips every year, with the cost of such trips surpassing the annual support of all long-term missionaries combined. Priest calls this explosion of participation, “the first mission movement in church history that is based largely on the needs of the missionary.” Other critics have suggested that these trips condition the people in the host countries to wait for help from their wealthier visitors rather than building their own ministries, businesses, and programs. In the process, pastors and other Christian leaders become glorified tour guides, the indigenous Christian communities develop a sense of dependence, and the more foundational work of missions—discipleship and church-planting—gets pushed to the back burner.
I’d like to throw this open to the Internet Monk community for comment. Talk to us about the good, the bad, the beneficial, and the detrimental of short-term mission trips. What questions and concerns do you have about them? What unqualified positive things do you have to say about them?
Everyone is welcome, but I would especially love to hear from:
- Believers who have led and been on these trips.
- People in mission organizations that sponsor these trips.
- Pastors and church leaders in churches from which you and/or your parishioners have taken trips.
- Career missionaries. What is your view of these trips?
- People in places where these trips are taken. What impact have short-term teams had (good/bad/other) in your communities and churches?
- Folks who have supported others financially and in other ways to take these trips.
Step up to the mic!
For further reading: Check out the 4-part series at Christianity Today that starts with an exchange called, “Are Short-Term Missions Good Stewardship?”